Brian Burke has left his GM post and is now working as a consultant for the Ducks, most likely paving his way for a move to Toronto. Recently Brian Burke was rated the number 1 General Manager in the Hockey News annual rankings. He also tops the wish list of most Leaf fans as as the media anointed saviour of God’s team.
But is he really the best GM for the Maple Leafs?
I guess it depends on what tonic you are searching for to cure your ails. If you want to rip down the foundation and rebuild from scratch then Burke is the wrong guy for the job. His work history is littered with mediocre drafts and slightly above average trades. He is credited with the rebuild of the Canucks into contenders and with the turnaround of the Mighty Ducks.
I tend to disagree and feel the heavy lifting was completed before his arrival in either city.
The Hartford Whaler era cannot be analyzed properly as he was only afforded a year as the GM before being fired. His first and only draft for the Whalers yielded the following players:
Robert Petrovicky , Andrei Nikolishin , Litvinov Chemopetrol, Ken Belanger, Konstantin Korotkov, Greg Zwakman, Steve Halko and Joakim Esbjors
Hardly an impressive crop of NHL caliber players, but seeing as he was a rookie and was not really afforded a real opportunity his results are really inconclusive. If anything the poor performance on the ice allowed the Whalers to manoeuvre into a position to draft Chris Pronger.
Burke has been widely credited with turning around the Vancouver Canucks from doormat into Stanley Cup contender. I believe that Pat Quinn and MIke Keenan’s contribution’s were just as important in the ascendence of the Canucks in the early 2000s.
When Burke arrived in Vancouver he had a core of Markus Naslund, Todd Bertuzzi, Pavel Bure, Alexander Mogilny, Adrian Aucoin, Brett Hedican, Matthias Ohlund, and Garth Snow. Along with Quinn draft picks Brett Hedican, Peter Schaefer and Brent Sopel.
Burke allowed Messier to become a Free Agent, traded Pavel Bure for Ed Jovanovski and Alexander Mogilny for Brendan Morrison. Both trades worked well for the Canucks as Bure coming off 58 and 59 goal seasons hurt his knee in Florida and could never recapture the explosiveness that made him the best goal scorer in the league. Mogilny was just beginning the descent and he acquired the center piece for what would become the league’s most dangerous line.
He also reacquired Trevor Linden as a Free Agent, traded for Felix Potvin, traded Adrian Aucoin for Dan Cloutier and Sami Salo for Peter Schaefer.
Although his draft results netted him the Sedin Twins his 6 drafts (1998-2003) in Vancouver yielded very little NHL talent
http://hockeydb.com/ihdb/draft/teams/dr000039.htmlThe Canucks under Brian Burke had a combined record of 209-181-68-24 and made the playoffs 4 of 6 seasons winning 1 round in the Stanley Cup playoffs.
Burke benefited greatly from a youthful nucleus provided by Quinn and tradeable assets in Mogilny and Bure. Although he had strong regular season success he never addressed the secondary scoring problems and the Canucks were hampered by average goaltending. Burke left the Canucks with very little in their farm system and an aging fading core of Bertuzzi, Naslund, Jovanovski and Cloutier.
Burke the smart man he is leaped to a situation with great possibilities created by his successor Bryan Murray. The Ducks had lots of cap space and had restocked their minor league system with elite level prospects Corey Perry, Ryan Getzlaf , Dustin Penner and Joffrey Lupul. He inherited a franchise goalie in JS Giguere and an elite backup in Ilya Bryzgalov.
Burke made a shrewd move of dumping Sergei Federov’s salary and acquiring Francois Beauchemin. With a strong young core and tons of cap space he signed the crown jewel of the Stanley Cup champion New Jersey Devils, Scott Niedermayer. Burke then came within a hair of landing Sydney Crosby and settled for Bobby Ryan passing on Jack Johnson, Carey Price, Anze Kopitar, Marc Staal, Tuuka Rask and Andrew Cogliano.
He then used a combination of the youth he inherited and his ample cap space to acquire Chris Pronger from the Ducks for Lupul, two first rounders and a 2nd round pick.
Although his draft record cannot be acurately judged after only 3 seasons, their system is not overflowing with elite young talent anymore.
http://ducks.nhl.com/team/app/?service=page&page=NHLPage&id=17374Burke helped to change the face of the Ducks in 2 seasons and did a strong job in doing so. But he bailed on a franchise that was ailing from the Bertuzzi fiasco and jumped in bed with a franchise in great position for the future.
Which brings me to what the Maple Leafs need. If the Leafs want a GM who is going to come in and rebuild the franchise from the ground up like the Canadiens and Penguins have, then Brian Burke is not the man for the job.
His draft record is poor and he will be entering a situation which lacks the cap space and emerging superstar talent (Bertuzzi, Naslund, Getzlaf, Perry) to make an immediate impact. He lacks the quality assets to flip for quality players like Brendan Morrison and Ed Jovanovski.
Even if he is able pull a rabbit out of the hat, and steal an elite player? Where is the glut of $800,000 forwards and defencemen to push this franchise forward?
He may be able to provide a quick turnaround, but is that going to cure what ails the crown jewel of MLSE? Will a couple of playoff appearances change the long term future of the franchise? Will Free Agent band aids mark any substantial changes from the Pat Quinn/JFJ era’s?
Unfortuantely I think that Burke is the headline splashing move that MLSE is looking for. Personally as a Canadiens fan Ken Holland, Doug Armstrong and Dave Nonis would worry me a lot more than Brian Burke.
But I am sure Leaf Nation will eat this up and believe that Burke can create a miracle and bring them back to contender status within a couple of years. The Leafs need to go back to square one and set their sights on John Tavares and rebuilding a depleted farm system, not concern themselves with PR moves.
So for somebody who revels in the Leafs mistakes I welcome the hiring of Brian Burke. Nobody likes to hear themselves speak more than Mr. Burke and with all of the media coverage that is aimed at the Leafs his ego will get it’s much needed spotlight.
Over to you Dick Peddie. I am looking forward to the Press Conference where you and Brian Burke continually pat yourselves on the back.